When it comes to training and hunting with your dog. Finding the best dog training collar is one of the tools quite necessary for your gun dog. With leading manufacturers making numerous models and features. Sometimes it’s hard to sift through and find the best one. Therefore, we have tried and test the best dog training collars for waterfowl hunters. Don’t get me wrong dog training collars can be used in many situations like upland hunting and basic obedience. However, when it comes to waterfowl hunting finding a dog training collar that can withstand the conditions and water is a necessity, and not all brands are created equal.
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainer –
Price – Average | Rating – 9.9
When it comes to looking for the best dog training collar, SportDOG has to be one of the top contenders. With numerous models and features, they truly tailor to dogs, hunting dogs to be specific. Specifically, the SportDOG 425 is a dog training collar that can get the job done for any hunting situation. It’s one of the most versatile and budget-friendly models available.
As you look to finding the best dog training collar and you have multiple dogs you training or even hunt with the SportDOG 425 allows you to add up to three collars to one receiver. Therefore, you have the ability to train three separate dogs at the same time. However, if you’re like me and you lose a collar or two, it’s nice to know you’ll be able to purchase another collar without buying a whole unit. The collar fits dogs that are eight pounds or more, (never seen a duck dog that small but it’s possible), and it fits your dog’s neck from 5″ – 22″ around. Therefore, giving you the ability to ensure you get a secure and proper placement on your dog’s neck.
Waterproof & Range –
Whenever you look for a dog training collar for duck hunting. Range and water resistance are two of the top features to look for. The SportDOG 425 has a max range of 500 yards and can withstand submersion of 25 feet. I don’t know about you but my lab can’t dive to 25 feet, so this collar gives plenty of range and security when it comes to duck hunting training.
Battery Life –
The SportDog 425 is equipped with a rechargeable lithium-ion battery that provides you with 50-70 constant hours of use and training. The best advice is to remember to shut off the receiver and collar when not in use. If you do a 30 min training session each day you can easily get a few weeks worth of use on one charge. However, when you do need to charge it, it only takes about two hours to receive a full charge.
Remote Transmitter –
The last important feature needed in a dog training collar is the stimulation and level control. The 425 offers seven levels of static stimulation from low to medium. Plus it allows you to deliver a momentary or nick correction, or a continuous stimulation. Additionally, you have the option to train with a buzz or tone feature. These can come in really nice for young dogs or veteran hunting dogs that are familiar with a dog training collar.
The best feature of the SportDOG 425 is that you can select one of two different 425 models. One of them has low to medium stimulation and the other is a medium to high stimulation. Therefore, if you have a larger breed or a tougher dog going with the medium to high is recommended. Honestly ever dog is a little different, I’ve seen some dogs that can take the highest stimulation and they barely feel a thing.
The second best feature that the SportDOG 425 has is a low battery indicator that reminds you to put your dog training collar back on the charger. I always check mine before training sessions or hunts. I hate not having the security or tool to help correct my lab when working bumpers or out in the field.
The biggest issue I’ve seen with this model is that they can lose their charging ability after months of use. However, I know that SportDOG as 6 days a week customer service line and are always willing to work with replacing the batteries especially considering they have a one year warranty associated with the 425 dog training collar.
Price – Above Average | Rating – 9.6
Don’t let the name of Garmin fool you, Tritronics is the heart that beats inside these dog training collars. A few years ago Garmin bought Tritronics and took over the brand and system. Thankfully they didn’t change much because Garmin/Tritronics makes one of the best dog training collars.
Similar to the SportDog 425, but on steroids the Garmin Pro 70 delivers the ability for up to six total additional collars that can be transmitted with one receiver. As a result, you have the ability to train multiple dogs with one receiver, just simply add on additional collars. This way if you have a couple dogs and are working some drills, you don’t have to swap the collars each rotation. Additionally, the collar has a contact point set that is included in your purchase. This way you can set the depth required for your dog. Some dogs with longer coats, a Golden Retriever, for example, may require longer contact points to ensure good contact around your dog’s neck. It’s nice to have the ability to change these out and get the correct size.
Waterproof & Range –
The Garmin Pro 70 is a fully functional duck hunting and dog training collar. The receiver is rated to IPX7 or suitable for splashes, rain, snow or wet conditions. Whereas, the collar is rated 1 ATM, where it can be submerged into water for extended periods of time. Overall, you never have to worry about getting your dog training collar damaged due to water. On top of the water rating you’ll find that the collar and receiver have a bulletproof design. They allow for all the bumps, drops, and rugged adventures you can put it one. I couldn’t even count how many times I’ve dropped mine and it still works flawlessly.
Battery Life –
Garmin has built the Pro 70 with a rechargeable lithium-ion battery that provides over 80 hours of use on one single charge. I’ve never left mine on for that long of a continuous stretch. However, I do know that a barely charge mine but once a month and it always seems to work. As long as I remember to shut it off between uses. However, I could see when training a young dog where the use would be higher, that you may not get that much battery life.
Remote Transmitter –
The Garmin Pro 70 dog training collar is one of the longest transmitting devices on this list. The collar and receiver will work out to a mile. A two inch fixed antenna is built into the transmitter that allows the long-distance capability. I’ve never experienced my dog getting that far away from me. However, knowing the range isn’t limited to any hunting situation gives me a sense of relief. When it comes to settings and stimulation the Pro 70 is the best dog training collar model for the money since it has six stimulation levels ranging from 1-6, and a tone setting. Plus all of it can be selected with a selection dial located at the top of the transmitter. Therefore, making it extremely easy to adjust settings on the fly.
When it comes to early morning duck hunts and getting up before the sunrise. Lights are your number one friend when the moon is hidden behind some cloud cover. I know for a fact I’m usually lost without my headlamp in the morning. Now Garmin thought of everything with the Pro 70, built into the collar is a light indicator for your hunting dog. All you have to do is select the light indicator on the transmitter and you can turn the collar light on. Giving light to knowing where your dog is at all times in the morning dark. I know for myself I own a black lab and they are basically ghosts at an early light unless you have a dog vest or bright reflective collar on them. So the light indicator is an awesome benefit when you choose the Garmin Pro 70 model.
It’s hard Garmin could pack more into their collar, but they also have a bark collar feature included. The Barklimitor uses intuitive accelerometer-based bark indicators to distinguish between barks and vocalization to help count and eliminating unwanted barking. Therefore, if you’re at the dinner after your hunt and you have a noise duck dog. The collar will even be working when you can’t be by your dog. It’s a pretty neat feature for a gun dog collar.
I’m not sure if you’ve purchased other items or products from Garmin, but their products can be costly. The Garmin Pro 70 is just that, it’s on the higher end of the e collars. However, I will say that the dog training collar is one of the most durable and you pay for quality when you want the best dog training collar.
Price – Average | Rating – 9.3
Built on a foundation of over 20 years, Dogtra is determined to bring the best dog training collars to gun dog owners. The 1900s series is Dogtras most precise and one of the best training tools you can buy from them. Built for performance when it comes to training, hunting, or competition trials. Dogtra has to be apart of our best dog training collar list for those reasons alone. However, what makes it worth the spot?
Similar to other collars on this list, it’s capable of adding additional collars. However, it won’t have the number of collar additions as the Garmin Pro 70 e collar does. Instead, the Dogtra 1900s is built for the hunter. Specifically the duck hunter, maybe I’m biased waterfowl hunter, but it has all the features necessary for your duck dog which keeps it pretty simple. The collar system features one of the most robust stimulation settings out of any collar on this list. Making it one of the best dog training collars for your personal dog. We will get into the number of settings under the “Remote Transmitter” section. As I stated earlier the kit has the essentials, included in the box is a transmitter, receiver, battery charger, test light, and owner’s manual.
Waterproof & Range –
The dog collar system is fully waterproof rated to an IPX9K rating meaning they can withstand high heat and water pressure. This is the best dog training collar if you are hunting only from water, the system can’t be matched for its waterproof rating. Plus with the collars ergonomic curved design it fits your dog’s neck very easily and comfortably. Plus the collar is quite slim, so it won’t get caught up in reeds, marsh grass, or corn stalks. I know some of the cheap dog training collars can be quite bulky.
Battery Life –
The collar has a rechargeable battery that can be charged in a rapid 2 hours. Therefore, for back to back hunts, this collar will always be fully charged. The battery life will easily last 60 hours and over numerous hunts, if you remember to shut the devices off.
Remote Transmitter –
This is where the Dogtra begins to shine and stand out as one of the best dog training collar models. It has a whopping 0-127 stimulation settings. That’s not a typo “127” different settings to custom set the level required to correct and training your hunting dog. The best part is that it has an LCD display screen that provides you a clear view of what setting you are on and a patented Rheostat Dial to help increase or decrease the stimulation. The added benefit to the display is that it also has a battery life indicator.
Nonetheless, with 127 different settings, 3/4 mile range, and enhanced contact points, you’ll be sure to find a setting that is perfect for training your dog. As for the type of stimulation you can deliver, the Dogtra has a nick, constant and HPP vibration settings when training your dog. We found the vibration setting to be great for old dogs and new pups.
The two best benefits that the Dogtra 1900s has is that it has a 2-year limited lifetime warranty. No other dog training collar matches that type of warranty. For myself, I know the abuse the collars take when training and hunting. Therefore, it’s nice to see a company stand by their products and make them truly tested for waterfowl hunting. The seconds best feature of the Dogtra collar is the belt clip, it sounds small, but most of the receivers are designed to be hung with a lanyard. Well, most transmitters are quite heavy around the neck, so having a belt clip is really nice for training and in some situations hunting.
The largest drawback to the collar is that it’s designed for dogs over 35 pounds. I know almost every duck hunting dog that I’ve hunted over is above that. But some upland hunting breeds may have some concern when using this model. However, if the collar fits your dog and with 127 settings the Dogtra 1900s is one of the best dog training collar models for duck hunters.
Price – Below Average | Rating – 9.0
If you’re looking for the best dog training collar and yet you don’t want to spend a fortune. The Garmin Delta XC is going to be the best option without having to take any compromises. From changeable contact points to a full 18 levels of continuous stimulation the Garmin Delta XC is one of the best dog training collars.
Garmin decided to take the technology that Tri-Tronics was so well known for and create a less expensive, yet fully equipped dog training collar. It gives you the capabilities to run three dogs with one receiver and still have up to a half mile of range. If you are planning on getting a e collar for yourself and your not a kennel or dog trainer this collar is more than sufficient for waterfowl hunting.
The best feature that we liked with the Delta XC was that it has a lightweight small receiver. Meaning you can work the device with one hand very easily, my wife even enjoyed this one a little more than the larger models. As the front of the device has three easy soft buttons for stimulation and correcting.
Waterproof & Range –
When it comes to looking for the best dog training collar water resistance is a number one indicator if it will work for duck hunting. The Garmin Delta XC, is rated to IPX7 meaning it can be used in any waterfowl hunting situation from land to rivers and ponds. The Delta XC is a very versatile collar don’t think that you can’t use it for upland hunting as well. It’s truly a great bargain.
Battery Life –
The Garmin Delta XC is fixed with a rechargeable lithium-ion battery in both the transmitter and the dog collar. Therefore, a couple hours on the charger and you’ll have over 60-80 hours of use on a single charge. Hence, you’ll easily have a weekend of hunting that can be done on one single charge. Plus similar to the Dogtra model, the Delta XC has a display on the device to indicate battery level and life left. It’s really a nice feature when it comes to finding the best dog training collar.
Remote Transmitter –
The remote is a little different than the Pro 70 model, it has 0-18 different stimulation settings so you can tailor to your dog’s needs. However, on top of that, it’s displayed on an LCD lens to show the settings. The Delta XC is one of the easiest models to run and is extremely user-friendly. Plus from nick, continuous, to vibration the Delta XC will provide a fully functional training collar. The functions and capabilities are unmatched for the low price that the Delta XC model is. I wish this was out when I first bought a dog training collar for my first pup.
The best benefit the Delta XC has to offer is the sleekness and low profile of the system. Most transmitters are quite bulky and heavy and always seem to get int he way while hunting. The Delta XC is perfect for hunting as the receiver is slim and easily fits in pants or coat pockets. Lastly, the price is hard to beat. For the included features and benefits the price is low and will get you started to training or hunting with your gun dog.
The largest issue I have with the Garmin Delta XC is that the device doesn’t seem as durable as the other models that Garmin makes. The cost benefit to keeping this more budget friendly means that it isn’t has durable as the Pro 70 or 550. Therefore, if you are training dogs all day every day this device may not stand up to the test. However, if you need a lightweight waterfowl hunting dog e collar this is the ticket.
Finding The Best Dog Training Collar –
When it comes to finding the best dog training collar look for e collars that are comfortable and slim for your dog. When it comes to waterfowl hunting it’s not uncommon for dogs to go full bore through cattails and reeds. Therefore, you don’t want a collar that sticks out and causes your dog to become snagged on their retrieves. Instead look for e collars that are low profile and fit snug to your dog’s neck. You also need to consider that the collar will be born for long periods of time. So the collar needs to be comfortable and suitable for your dog breed and size.
The second factor to consider when it comes to the collar is to ensure to select a dog training collar that has adjustable contact points or enhanced contact points that match your breed. Most retrievers have thin coats so any contact point will usually work. However, when it comes to Golden Retrievers and Chesapeake they have thick fur coats and if the contact points can’t meet your dog’s skin, the collar is going to be unsuccessful when it comes to stimulation settings.
Like most quality pieces of technology, finding the best dog training collar model for your dog can be an investment. Stay away from cheap non-branded collars they more than likely will work for around the house, but on that first duck hunt there going to fail due to the rugged conditions. Instead look for fully waterproof dog training collars that can withstand waterfowl hunting conditions. The good thing is that with e collars you get what you pay for. So when you opt to buy a high-end collar you’ll easily get numerous hunting and training seasons out of your collar.
How To Use A Dog Training Collar –
Are They Safe To Use –
The question and debate has surfaced multiple times when it comes to training dogs. Are dog training collars or shock collars safe for your dog? Thankfully when debates arise studies are soon to follow. No one ever wants to abuse or mistreat their hunting buddy. Leave it to hunters, we probably treat our dogs more like athletes than we do just a pet. From nutrition to kennels, to safety equipment gun dogs get the best gear. Therefore, there have been multiple studies conducted to show that there are little to no significant adverse results when using dog training collars. Electronic collars are even safe and humane according to the Animal Welfare Act.
As a result, dog training collars are tools for training and teaching dogs to learn the trades that they were breed to do over the past hundred plus years. Most of the time as a dog progresses from a young adolescent to adulthood a collar is more of a security blanket to keep your dog safe. They have a passion and drive to pursue a retrieve and at times it’s our responsibility as an owner to prevent it when conditions and elements are too unsafe. I’ve heard stories where an e collar saved their dog from pursuing crippled birds into deep icy water where conditions were unsafe.
Benefits of Using The Best Dog Training Collar –
Basic Obedience –
Using an e collar or dog training collar is one of the best ways to help train your dog some unwanted behaviors and learn some basic obedience. For example, no one likes a dog that jumps up on people or themselves. However, it’s natural instinct for dogs to do this as puppies and if not correct they carry this through adulthood. Therefore, when using a dog training collar you have the ability to correct and stimulate the bad behavior.
Shortly after a few occurrences, your dog will associate that unwanted behavior and you can prevent it before it becomes an issue or a concern. This is a great behavior and training exercise to teach your dog when your dog is around kids and older family members. The last thing you’d want is your dog injuring someone.
Reduce Unwanted Barking –
When it comes to barking dogs use it as the only form of vocal communication. Therefore it can and usually will become unwanted at some point in your dog’s life. Maybe your dog barks at home at unwanted times and situations an e collar can help correct the issue and teach them to stop. Some collars like the Garmin Pro 70 listed above even have bark limiting technology built into the dog training collar.
Therefore, if you have a dog or breed that barks, an e collar will surely help prevent the behavior and train your dog to remain calm and relaxed.
Aggression & Bad Behaviors –
The last two basic benefits for at home use for e collars is that they can help prevent aggression and destructive behaviors. By using the same drills and techniques listed above you can help prevent your dog from unwanted aggression or destructive behaviors.
Hunting Training –
When it comes to using a dog training collar for hunting training the capabilities are endless. From basic line work to casting, to working on blind retrieves, an e collar will help training and condition correct gun dog behavior. Check out how to train a labrador for more tips and guides to training.